Understanding the Investor Gap: Insights from Morningstar’s 2024 Report
Morningstar's annual "Mind the Gap" study highlights the persistent issue of the "investor gap"—the difference between a fund's reported total returns and the returns actually realized by the average investor. The 2024 report reveals that investors have missed out on approximately 1.1% of annual returns over the past decade due to poor timing of fund purchases and sales.
Key Findings
- Overall Investor Returns: Investors earned an average annual return of 6.3% over the past decade, compared to the 7.3% total return of their fund holdings. This 1.1% gap underscores the costs associated with mistimed transactions.
- Persistent Gap Across Categories: The gap was evident every year in the study, particularly in volatile periods like 2020. Allocation funds had the narrowest gap at 0.4%, while sector equity funds showed the largest gap at 2.6% annually.
- Comparison by Fund Types: Open-end funds performed slightly better than ETFs in terms of investor returns, with gaps of 1.0% and 1.1% respectively. Index funds outperformed active funds, with gaps of 0.8% and 1.2% respectively.
Actionable Insights
- Automate Investing: Consider allocation funds that automatically rebalance, reducing the need for frequent transactions.
- Focus on Low Volatility: Choosing funds with lower volatility could reduce the likelihood of making poor timing decisions.
- Think Like a Robo-Advisor: If you want to invest like a robo-advisor without paying the extra fees, you need to start thinking and acting like one. This means staying cool-headed, especially when the markets are choppy. How hard can that be? Spoiler alert: Actually, it’s pretty damn hard! But mastering this mindset can help you avoid the mistakes that lead to a widening investor gap.
- Reconsider ETFs for Convenience: While convenient, ETFs might tempt investors into frequent trading, potentially widening the gap between investor and fund returns. The flexibility they offer can be a double-edged sword, making it easier to react impulsively rather than staying the course.
- We like ETFS BUT...: If you know that you might be scared into selling at in inopportune times. You might want to consider a mutual fund or similar product. Where you cant actually trade on intra-day movements.
- We dont have to beat the market: We just have to stay in the market. And con
For more details, you can access the full report from Morningstar here.
Feel ready to start your investment journey? Open an account with one of our preferred partners below: